This article explores the challenge that most plea agreements in states such as Uganda might not conform to the legal contractual tenets, a gap that seemingly impugns their legitimacy rendering them unconscionable voidable contracts in law. To test this hypothesis, the author adopts the empirical data from her earlier Nakibuule (2023) case study of Uganda’s High Court bargained trials from 2014 to 2021 conducted in 11 High Court Circuits of Uganda: Arua , Fort Portal , Gulu , Kabale , Lira , Masaka , Masindi , Mbale , Mbarara , Mubende , Soroti ; and two High Court Divisions: Kampala High Court Criminal Division, and The International Criminal Division, Kololo . In that study, she employed qualitative doctrinal legal research and empirical narratives of a population sample of 66 convicts and 60 justice actors, with some of the field survey trends quantitatively explained. She selected its respondents using Quota; Purposive; Random; and Snowballing Sampling techniques. Analytical data evidences: how some accused enter plea agreements while minors; some others for the crimes they committed while minors but when grown into adults before trials; diverse fears and anxieties that most battle with during the negotiations, mostly amidst non-conducive ambience, negatively impact their sobriety to contract legit bargains; and the coercive and undue influence traits induce several of them into involuntary plea-agreements showcasing limited freedom to contract. These findings suggest that plea agreements can be irrevocable due to the accused’s limited contractual capacity and freedom to contract them. The article offers both legal and institutional reforms to rethink plea bargains as legit contracts for Uganda that can also extrapolate to other jurisdictions.
KeywordsPlea AgreementsUnconscionable ContractsAccused Contractual CapacityFreedom to ContractUganda
(1890). De Francesco v Barnum (1890) 45 ChD 430.
(1894). Clements v London & North Western Railway Company [1894] 2 QB 482 (CA, June 15, 1894).
(1894). Flower v London & North Western Railway Company (1894), 2 QB 65 (CA).
(1908). Nash v Inman [1908] 2 KB 1 (CA, 5 March 1908).
(1913). Roberts v Gray [1913] 1 KB 520 (SC April 23, 1913).
(1965). Chaplin v Leslie Frewen (Publishers) Ltd [1965] EWCA Civ J1025-2, [1966] 1 Ch 71(CA, October 25, 1965).
(1997). The Children A ct. 1997. (Revised 2016), (Commencement 01/08/1997), Pub. L. No. Cap 62, Cap 62, Red Volume III, Title No. IX, Laws of Uganda, 7th Edition, 2024. https://publications.ulrc.go.ug/laws-of-uganda/26?title=VOLUME%20III
(2010). The Contrac ts Act, Pub. L. No. Act 7 of 2010, Cap 284, Title No. XXXVI, Red Volume XII, Laws of Uganda, 7th Edition, 2024. https://publications.ulrc.go.ug/laws-of-uganda/35?title=VOLUME%20XII
(2019). JAJ2(n2)/JASA2(n4)., (Judge) HCT, Criminal Division, Kampala (Host). (2019, February 07), [Interview Transcript, Personal Communication].
(2019). JAJ3(n2)., (Judge) HCT Circuit, Masaka (Host). (2019, March 06), [Interview Transcript, Personal Communication].
(2019). JAJ4(n2)., (Judge) HCT Circuit Mbale (Host). (2019, March 07), [Interview Transcript, Personal Communication].
(2019). JAP1(n6)., (Officer in Charge) Kampala (Luzira Upper) Prison (Host). (2019, February 14), [Interview Transcript, Personal Communication].
(2019). JAP2(n6)., (Officer in Charge) Kampala, (Luzira Women) Prison (Host). (2019, February 15), [Interview Transcript, Personal Communication].
(2019). JAR1(n3)., (Registrar) HCT, Kampala Criminal Division (Host). (2019, February 07), [Interview Transcript, Personal Communication].
(2019). JAR2(n3)., (Registrar) HCT, International Criminal Division (ICD) Kampala (Host). (2019, February 15), [Interview Transcript, Personal Communication].
(2019). JASB1(n5)., (Advocate) ULS, Kampala (Host). (2019, February 18), [Interview Transcript, Personal Communication].
(2019). MC1(n1). (Accused Respondent). Kampala (Luzira Upper Security) Prison (Host). (2019, February 14) [Interview Transcript, Personal Communication].
(2019). MC12(n1). (Accused Respondent). Kampala (Luzira Upper) Prison (Host). (2019, February 14) [Interview Transcript, Personal Communication].
(2019). MC2(n1). (Accused Respondent). Kampala (Luzira Upper) Prison (Host). (2019, February 14) [Interview Transcript, Personal Communication].
(2019). MC3(n1). (Accused Respondent). Kampala (Luzira Upper) Prison (Host). (2019, February 14) [Interview Transcript, Personal Communication].
(2019). MC6(n1). (Accused Respondent). Kampala (Luzira Upper) Prison (Host). (2019, February 14) [Interview Transcript, Personal Communication].
(2019). MC8(n1). (Accused Respondent). Lira (Main) Prison (Host). (2019, September 06) [Interview Transcript, Personal Video Conferenced Communication].
(2019). WC1(n1). (Accused Respondent). Kampala (Luzira Women) Prison (Host). (2019, February 15) [Interview Transcript, Personal Communication].
(2020). Agaba and 2 Others v Uganda (Criminal Appeal 139 of 2017) [2020] UGCA 2143 (13 October 2020) (Musoke. E., Musota. S., Kasule. R, JJJA).
(2020). JAJ6(n2)., (Resident Judge) HCT Circuits, Arua and Gulu (Host). (2020, May 20), [Interview Transcript, Personal Communication].
(2020). MC19(n1). (Accused Respondent). Mbale (Maluku) Prison (Host). (2020, September 04) [Interview Transcript, Personal Video Conferenced Communication].
(2021). JAP10(n6)., (Officer in Charge) Masindi, (Main) Prison (Host). (2021, February 12), [Interview Transcript, Personal Communication].
(2021). JAP11(n6)., (Officer in Charge) Masindi (Main) Prison (Host). (2021, March 05), [Interview Transcript, Personal Communication].
(2021). JAP12(n6)., (Officer in Charge) Kabale (Ndorwa) Prison (Host). (2021, March 20), [Interview Transcript, Personal Communication].
(2021). JAP5(n6)., (Officer in Charge) Gulu (Main) Prison (Host). (2021, January 11), [Interview Transcript, Personal Communication].
(2021). JAP6(n6)., (Prisons Welfare Officer) Masindi (Main) Prison (Host). (2021, March 11), [Interview Transcript, Personal Communication].
(2021). JAP8(n6)., (Welfare Officer) Arua, (Main) Prison (Host). (2021, April 22), [Interview Transcript, Personal Communication].
(2021). JAP9(n6)., (Officer in Charge). Arua, (Main) Prison (Host). (2021, April 22), [Interview Transcript, Personal Communication].
(2021). MC24(n1). (Accused Respondent). Masaka (Main) Prison (Host). (2021, March 04) [Interview Transcript, Personal Communication].
(2021). MC26(n1). (Accused Respondent). Masaka (Main) Prison (Host). (2021, March 04) [Interview Transcript, Personal Video Conferenced Communication].
(2021). MC28(n1). (Accused Respondent). Masindi (Main) Prison (Host). (2021, March 12) [Interview Transcript, Personal Video Conferenced Communication].
(2021). MC34(n1). (Accused Respondent). Soroti (Main) Prison (Host). (2021, April 10) [Interview Transcript, Personal Video Conferenced Communication].
(2021). MC36(n1). (Accused Respondent). Soroti (Main) Prison (Host). (2021, April 12) [Interview transcript, Personal Video Conferenced Communication].
(2021). MC37(n1). (Accused Respondent). Fort Portal (Katogyo Male) Prison (Host). (2021, April 18 and 21) [Interview Transcript, Personal Video Conferenced Communication].
(2021). MC39(n1). (Accused Respondent). Fort Portal (Katogyo) Prison (Host). (2021, April 21) [Interview Transcript, Personal Video Conferenced Communication].
(2021). MC42(n1). (Accused Respondent). Kabale (Ndorwa) Prison (Host). (2021, April 22) [Interview Transcript, Personal Communication].
(2021). MC44(n1). (Accused Respondent). Mbarara (Kakyeka) Prison (Host). (2021, April 27) [Interview Transcript, Personal Video Conferenced Communication].
(2021). WC12(n1). (Accused Respondent). Arua Main Prison (Host). (2021, March 17) [Interview Transcript, Personal Video Conferenced Communication].
(n.d.). Compromise . Oxford Languages Dictionary. https://www.google.com/search?q=compromise+meaning
Alati, D. (2015). Plea Bargaining and the Trial Penalty in Canada. International Journal of Human Rights and Constitutional Studies, 3, 206-219. https://doi.org/10.1504/ijhrcs.2015.072474
Alkon, C. (2010). Plea Bargaining as a Legal Transplant: A Good Idea for Troubled Criminal Justice Systems. Transnational Law & Contemporary Problems, 19, 355-418.
Alschuler, A. W. (1976). The Trial Judge’s Role in Plea Bargaining, Part I. Columbia Law Review, 76, 1059-1154. https://doi.org/10.2307/1121673
Alschuler, A. W. (1979). Plea Bargaining and Its History. Law & Society Review, 13, 211-245. https://doi.org/10.2307/3053250
Anguzu, J. (2021). JAP7(n6)., (Superintendent of Prisons (SP)) Soroti Main Prison, Uganda Management Institute Campus (Host). (2021, April 24), [Interview Transcript, Personal Communication].
Ashworth, A., Redmayne, M., & Campbell, L. (2019). The Criminal Process (5th ed.). Oxford University Press.
Bibas, S. (2004). Plea Bargaining Outside the Shadow of Trial. Harvard Law Review, 117, 2463-2547. https://doi.org/10.2307/4093404
Birke, R. (2007). Role of Trial in Promoting Cooperative Negotiation in Criminal Practice. Marquette Law Review, 91 , 39-83. https://scholarship.law.marquette.edu/mulr/vol91/iss1/4
Church Jr., T. W. (1979). In Defense of “Bargain Justice”. Law & Society Review, 13, 509-525. https://doi.org/10.2307/3053266
Constitution of the Republic of Uganda (1995). (Commencement 08/10/1995), Pub. L. No. Title No 1, Red Volume I, Title No 1, Laws of Uganda, 7th Edition, 2024. https://publications.ulrc.go.ug/laws-of-uganda/24?title=VOLUME%20I
Crocker, O. J. (2022). The Separability Thesis: A Comparison Between Natural Law and Legal Positivism. https://philpapers.org/archive/CROTST-4.pdf
Di Luca, J. (2005). Expedient McJustice or Principled Alternative Dispute Resolution? A Review of Plea Bargaining in Canada. Criminal Law Quarterly, 50, 14-66.
Easterbrook, F. H. (1983). Criminal Procedure as a Market System. The Journal of Legal Studies, 12, 289-332. https://doi.org/10.1086/467725
Easterbrook, F. H. (1992). Plea Bargaining as Compromise. The Yale Law Journal, 101, 1969-1978. https://doi.org/10.2307/796953
Elubu, M. (2020). JAJ5 (n2)., (Judge) HCT Circuits, Kabale and Jinja (Host). (2020, April 29), [Interview Transcript, Personal Communication].
Fisher, R., Ury, W. L., & Patton, B. (2011). Getting to Yes: Negotiating Agreement without Giving . Penguin Publishing Group.
Garner, B. A. (2009). Black’s La w Dictionary Standard (9th ed.). West Group.
Green, T. S., Ward, J. D., & Arcuri, A. (1975). Plea Bargaining: Fairness and Inadequacy of Representation. Columbia Human Rights Law Review, 7, 495-527.
Grossman, G. M., & Katz, M. L. (1983). Plea Bargaining and Social Welfare. The American Economic Review, 73, 749-757. http://www.jstor.org/stable/1816572
Hart, H. L. A., & Green, L. (2012). The Concept of Law. Clarendon Law Series (3rd ed.). Oxford University Press.
Jones, D. A. (1978). Negotiation, Ratification, and Rescission of the Guilty Plea Agreement: A Contractual Analysis and Typology. Duquesne Law Review, 17, 591-632. https://dsc.duq.edu/dlr/vol17/iss3/3
Jung, H. (1997). Plea Bargaining and Its Repercussions on the Theory of Criminal Procedure. European Journal of Crime, Criminal Law and Criminal Justice, 5, 112-122. https://doi.org/10.1163/157181797x00464
Keitirima, J. E. (2019). (Judge). Kampala, HCT Land Division (Host). (2019, March 03), [Interview Transcript, Personal Communication].
Kuunya, H. (2019). JASB2(n5)., (Advocate) Lecturer, Law Development Centre (LDC), Kampala, Makerere (Host). (2019, March 13), [Interview Transcript, Personal Communication].
Kyobika, W. (2021). JAAC1(n8)., (Magistrate) Judicial Training Institute Research Unit (Host). (2021, February 01) [Interview Transcript, Personal Communication].
Landes, W. M. (1971). An Economic Analysis of the Courts. The Journal of Law and Economics, 14, 61-107. https://doi.org/10.1086/466704
Lubaale, E. C. (2016). The Advent of Plea Bargaining in Uganda: Is Uganda’s Criminal Justice System Cognizant of What It Is Up Against? East African Journal of Peace and Human Rights, 22, 136-173.
Mbazira, C. (2021). JAAC3(n8). (Legal Academic, Human Rights). Makerere School of Law (Host). (2021, June 15), [Interview Transcript, Personal Communication].
Meyer, J. F. (2024). Plea Barg aining. Encyclopedia Britannica. https://www.britannica.com/topic/plea-bargaining
Morauta, J. (2004). Three Separation Theses. Law and Philosophy, 23, 111-135.
Nakibuule, G. K. (2017). The Impact of Plea Bargaining on the Criminal Justice Delivery: A Case Study of the Uganda High Court Criminal Trials. AuthorHouse.
Nakibuule, G. K. (2023). An Accused’s Self-Incrimination to End Trial? Plea Bargaining and the Right to a Fair Hearing in Uganda . Master’s Thesis, Makerere University. http://hdl.handle.net/10570/13013
Nakigudde, M. (2019). JASA1(n4). (Senior State Attorney, ODPP National Coordinator in charge Plea Bargaining) ODPP Headquarters (Host). (2019, August 6), [Interview Transcript, Personal Communication].
Namawejje, S. E. (2021). JASB4(n5)., (Advocate) ULS, Kampala (Host). (2021, August 24), [Interview Transcript, Personal Communication].
Namubiru, S. M. (2022). JACSO2 (n11)., (Chief Executive Officer) LASPNET Mengo, Kampala (Host). (2022, March 08), [Interview Transcript, Personal Communication].
Ninsiima, M. (2019). JAP4 (n6). (Senior Superintendent of Prisons (SSP)). Lira Main Prison (Host). (2019, November 17), [Interview Transcript, Personal Communication].
ODPP Plea Bargain Guidelines (2021). Office of the Director of Public Prosecution (ODPP) (unpublished) .
Oyugi, Q. (2019). JASB3 (n5)., (Advocate) ULS Lira (Host). (2019, September 01), [Interview Transcript, Personal Communication].
Persaud, S. N. (2009). Conceptualizations of Legalese in the Course of Due Process, from Arrest to Plea Bargain: The Perspectives of Disadvantaged Offenders. North Carolina Central Law Review, 31, 107-149. https://archives.law.nccu.edu/ncclr/vol31/iss2/2
Rugadiya, A. (2020). (Retired), JAJ7(n2). (Resident Judge) HCT Circuit, Masindi (Host). (2020, May 09), [Interview Transcript, Personal Communication].
Russell, J., & Hollander, N. (2017). The Disappearing Trial: The Global Spread of Incentives to Encourage Suspects to Waive Their Right to a Trial and Plead Guilty. New Journal of European Criminal Law, 8, 309-322. https://doi.org/10.1177/2032284417722281
Ruttenburg, E. A. (1979). Plea Bargaining Analytically-The Nash Solution to the Landes Model. The American Journal of Criminal Law, 7, 323-353.
Scott, R. E., & Stuntz, W. J. (1992). Plea Bargaining as Contract. The Yale Law Journal, 101, 1909-1968. https://doi.org/10.2307/796952
Shapiro, S. J. (2011). Leg ality. Harvard University Press. https://doi.org/10.2307/j.ctvjnrsd5
Taylor, J. R. (2011). Restoring the Bargain: Examining Post-Plea Sentence Enhancement as an Unconscionable Violation of Contract Law. California Western Law Review, 48, 129-173. https://scholarlycommons.law.cwsl.edu/cwlr/vol48/iss1/4
The Law Reform Commission (1985). Rep ort on Minors’ Contracts. LRC 15 - 1985. The Law Reform Commission 1985. https://www.lawreform.ie/_fileupload/Reports/rMinorsContracts.htm
Turner, J. I. (2017). Plea Bargaining. In E. Luna (Ed.), 4. Reforming Criminal Justice. A Report by the Academy for Justice (pp. 73-100). Arizona State University. https://law.asu.edu/sites/default/files/pdf/academy_for_justice/4_Reforming-Criminal-Justice_Vol_3_Plea-Bargaining.pdf
Tyler, T. R. (2007). Does the American Public Accept the Rule of Law? The Findings of Psychological Research on Deference to Authority. De Paul Law Review, 56, 661-694. http://hdl.handle.net/20.500.13051/2409
Woodley, M., Adams, J., Atkin, L., Bainbridge, J., Clough, J., Gowland, J., Hewitson, R., Jackson, A., Judd, P., & Wolf, S. (2009). Osborn’s Concise Law Dictionary (11th ed.). Sweet & Maxwell.