Seeking to Establish a Better Balance between the Technical and Social Aspects of Assessment Practices in the English Inspection System; Aiming for a Community of Evaluation Practice
- 1 Churchpath Cottage, Over Stratton, South Petherton, UK
Abstract
This article highlights the need for a better balance between the technical and social aspects of assessment in the English inspection system of state schools. The author compares the theoretical belief that underpins current assessment practice with that which would need to be given more credence if teachers and inspectors are to become part of the same community of practice. This focus is seen as relevant at a time when inspection is once again under scrutiny following the death of a headteacher after a critical OFSTED judgement. Although it is understandable that teachers’ reaction to this news is to call for the abandonment of inspections an alternative scenario is offered that might allow all those involved in and with schools to become more equal partners in the evaluation process. By considering the different participants in terms of their “figured worlds” and introducing the concept of “roles by metaphor” as part of the feedback process the author offers a non-confrontational means of opening a meaningful dialogue between inspectors and teachers with the intention of improving pupil learning and teacher planning. For this model to be effective teachers must change role from delivery person to coach or scaffolder to allow pupils to change role from in attendance to absorbent recipient for example or metacognitive reflector. Similarly, inspectors will need to cease exerting power over teachers by changing role from judge to critical friend to communicate more effectively and lessen tension. Examples of how pedagogy and critical and social aspects of assessment affect pupil motivation, love of learning, independent thinking and grasp of subject matter are drawn from the writer’s experience of being part of the English state education system as a pupil, teacher, inspector, and researcher over the period 1949-2023 before sharing what happened when an inspection team trialled “ roles by metaphor ” during a sixth form inspection.
- Alexander, R. J. (2004). Towards Dialogic Teaching Rethinking Classroom Talk. Dialogos.
- Barnes, D., Britton, J., & Rosen, H. (1969). Language, the Learner and the School. Penguin.
- Black, P. (1995). Can Teachers Use Assessment to Improve Learning? British Journal of Curriculum and Assessment, 5, 7-11.
- Black, P. (2006). Formative Assessment the Power, the Prospect and the Problems. In Conference, Putting Assessment at the Heart of Learning Course Ref. 5100 (pp. 8-23). Creative Education Ltd.
- Black, P., & Wiliam, D. (1998). Beyond the Black Box. University of Cambridge School of Education.
- Broadfoot, P. (1999). Empowerment or Performativity? English Assessment Policy in the Late Twentieth Century. In The Assessment Reform Group Symposium on Assessment Policy (pp. 1-20).
- Bruner, J. S. (1986). Actual Minds Possible Worlds. Harvard University Press. https://doi.org/10.4159/9780674029019
- Burke, W. (2011). Log Jammed by Standard Assessment Tests: How Feedback Can Help Writers. Literacy, 45, 19-24. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1741-4369.2011.00575.x
- Carnahan, M. (1995). The Headaches of Double Vision: Reflections on the Process of Viewing the Principalship from Alternative Epistemological Perspectives. In The Annual Meeting of the Canadian Society for the Study of Education (pp. 1-25).
- Donmoyer, R. (1995). A Knowledge Base for Educational Administration Noted from the Field. In R. Donmoyer, M. Imber, & J. Scheurich (Eds.), The Knowledge Base in Educational Administration: Multiple Perspectives. SUNY Press.
- Dweck, C. S. (1986). Motivational Processes Affecting Learning. American Psychologist (Special Issue: Psychological Science and Education), 41, 1040-1048. https://doi.org/10.1037/0003-066X.41.10.1040
- Fullan, M. (1991). The New Meaning of Educational Change. Teachers’ College Press.
- Greenfield, T. (1993a). The Man Who Came through the Door in the Wall; Discovering Truth, Discovering Self, Discovering Organizations. In T. Greenfield, & P. Ribbins (Eds.), Greenfield on Educational Administration: Towards a Humane Science (pp 25-51). Routledge.
- Greenfield, T. (1993b). Re-Forming and Re-Evaluating Educational Administration: Whence Cometh the Phoenix? In T. Greenfield, & P. Ribbins (Eds.), Greenfield on Educational Administration: Towards a Humane Science (pp. 72-98). Routledge.