Ideal and Reality: The Reform of Juvenile Sealed Criminal Records in China
- 1 Criminal Legal Science, Beijing Normal University, Beijing, China
- 2 Criminal Legal Science, Beijing Normal University, Beijing, China
Abstract
Two-way protection is a special concept of juvenile justice. The connotation of this concept is to protect minors while taking the protection of social and public interests into account. Under this concept, the sealed criminal records system should balance the protection of minors and social defense effectively. However, the current system of juvenile sealed criminal records in China has some problems, such as improper disclosure of criminal information, rigid scope of sealed, hindering the employment of juveniles etc., which deviates from the concept of two-way protection principle. From the perspective of the principle of two-way protection, this paper explores the state-should-be of the system and analyzes the problems in judicial practice, and then perfects the current system from the aspects of concept correction and system docking, in order to make the system protect the interests of juvenile offenders to the greatest extent and take the protection of social interests into account.
- Beccaria, C. B. (1738-1794) (2017). On Crimes and Punishment (Huang feng, Trans.). Beijing: The Commercial Press (Original Work Published 1764). https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315125527
- Edwards, L. & Sagatun, L. J. (1976). A Study of Juvenile Record Sealing Practices in California. Pepperding Law Review, 4, 571.
- Lapp, K. (2106). American Criminal Record Exceptionalism. Ohio State Journal of Criminal Law, 14, 303.
- Selbin, J., McCrary, J., & Epstein, J. (2018). Unmarked: Criminal Record Clearing and Employment Outcomes. Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology, 108, 1.
- Smith, E. (2010). Sealing up the Problem of California’s One Strike and You’re Out Approach for Serious Juvenile Offenders. Thomas Jefferson Law Review, 32, 362-370.
- Wieder, N. (2014). Sealing the Record: An Analysis of Jurisdictional Variations of Juvenile Sex Offender Record Sealing Laws. Health Matrix, 24, 398.
- Zhao, B. Z. (2011). A Study on the Criminal Responsibility of Juvenile Delinquency. Journal of Shandong Public Security College, 3, 12.