Preliminary Risk Assessment Posed by Formaldehyde Residues in Clothing to Vietnamese Consumers
- 1 Osaka University, Division of Sustainable Energy and Environmental Engineering, Yamadaoka 2?1, Suita, Osaka 565-0871, Japan.
- 2 Osaka University, Division of Sustainable Energy and Environmental Engineering, Yamadaoka 2?1, Suita, Osaka, Japan.
Abstract
The assessment of potential health risks posed by formaldehyde in clothing to consumers is of increasing concern worldwide. Because of this, it is necessary to develop an exposure model that can realistically mimic clothes wearing conditions. This study aims to preliminarily develop a health risk assessment model for formaldehyde in clothing, and then to assess the potential health risk posed by formaldehyde in textiles to adults and infants in Vietnam using the model. Finally, this study aims to examine the plausibility of the adopted permissible values for formaldehyde in cloth- ing in Vietnam. In the model, two exposure factors for dermal exposure and overall exposure routes, i.e. sweat type and perspiration area, were considered. The margins of exposure (MOE) were calculated to estimate the health risks from worst case and average exposures. The assessment shows that acute exposure via inhalation can pose health risks to Vietnamese consumers in both cases. In regards to chronic exposure, dermal exposure is about four (for infants) and seven (for adults) times higher than exposure via inhalation, but no risks were found for average exposure. If a MOE of 100 is defined as ‘safe’ used, dermal and total chronic exposure to worst case cause potential risks, whereas no health risks were found for exposure to average case. With the model, the adopted Vietnamese permissible values for formaldehyde in clothing were assessed as not posing a health risk to Vietnamese consumers, hence they are accepted.
- Formaldehyde Council, Formaldehyde: Facts and Background Information, November, 2007. Internet available: http://www.formaldehyde.org/_base/pdf/fact_sheets/11_01_07 FormadehydeFactsandBackgroundInformation.pdf
- New Zealand Ministry of Consumer Affairs, “Evaluation of Alleged Unacceptable Formaldehyde Levels in Clothing”, 2007.
- European Commission (EC), “European Survey on the Release of Formaldehyde from Textiles”, 2007.
- C. D. G. Anton et al, “Formaldehyde-releasers: relationship to formaldehyde contact allergy. Formaldehyde- releasers in cloths: durable press chemical finishes?Part 1,” Contact Der-matitis Vol. 62, 2010, pp. 257-271.
- United States Government Accountability Office (GAO), “Formaldehyde in Textiles”, Report to Congressional Commit-tees, 2010.
- Vietnamese Ministry of Industry and Trading, “the Contempo-rary Regulation of Limits of Formaldehyde and Aromatic Amines Releasing from Dyes in Import Textiles”, November, 2009.
- A. J. Scheman, P. A. Carroll, K. H. Brown, and A. H. Osburn, “Formaldehyde-related textile allergy: an update”, Contact Dermatitis, Vol. 38, 1998, pp. 332-336.
- L. H. Paul et al., Survey and Health Assessment of Chemical Substances in Hobby Products for Children. Survey of chemi-cal substances in consumer product, No. 93, 2008.
- EU Federal Institute for Risk Assessment, Introduction to the Problems Surrounding Garment Textiles, June, 2007.
- The Danish EPA, Surveys on Chemicals in Consumer Products. Screening for Health Effects from Chemical Substances in Tex-tile Colorants, Survey No. 57, 2005.
- EC, Technical Guidance Document on Risk Assessment in Support of Directive 93/67/EEC on Risk Assessment for New Notified, European, 2003.
- Human and Environmental Risk Assessment (HERA), Ester-quats – Human Health Risk Assessment Report, November, 2009.
- VietChina Business (assessed August 2010) http://www.vietchinabusiness.vn/i-sng/tieu-im/15213-vai-nhiem-doc-vao-viet-nam
- V. N. Thai, A. Tokai, and D. T. Nguyen, Eco-labeling criteria for textile products with the support of textile flows: A case study of the Vietnamese textile industry. Journal of Sustainable Energy & Environment. [In reviewing]
- WHO, The table of height and weight of under-5-year-old chil-dren, 2008 (in Vietnamese) http://www.choicungbe.com/tre-thong-minh/bang-chieu-cao-va-can-nang-chuan-o-tre-duoi- 5-tuoi.ccb Vietnam National Institute of Physical Science, Survey of the height of Vietnamese people, 2010.