Phosphorus (P) risk indices are commonly used in the USA to estimate the field-scale risk of agricultural P runoff. Because the Ohio P Risk Index is increasingly being used to judge farmer performance, it is important to evaluate weighting/scoring of all P Index parameters to ensure Ohio farmers are credited for practices that reduce P runoff risk and not unduly penalized for things not demonstrably related to runoff risk. A sensitivity analysis provides information as to how sensitive the P Index score is to changes in inputs. The objectives were to determine 1) which inputs are most highly associated with P Index scores and 2) the relative impact of each input variable on resultant P Index scores. The current approach uses simulations across 6134 Ohio point locations and five crop management scenarios (CMSs), representing increasing soil disturbance. The CMSs range from all no-till, which is being promoted in Ohio, rotational tillage, which is a common practice in Ohio to full tillage to represent an extreme practice. Results showed that P Index scores were best explained by soil test P (31.9%) followed by connectivity to water (29.7%), soil erosion (13.4%), fertilizer application amount (11.3%), runoff class (9.5%), fertilizer application method (2.2%), and finally filter strip (2.0%). Ohio P Index simulations across CMSs one through five showed that >40% scored <15 points (low) while <1.5% scored >45 points (very high). Given Ohio water quality problems, the Ohio P Index needs to be stricter. The current approach is useful for Ohio P Index evaluations and revision decisions by spatially illustrating the impact of potential changes regionally and state-wide.
KeywordsOhio P IndexSensitivity AnalysisP Index SimulationsRUSLE2 SimulationsCrop Management Simulations
USDA-NASS (National Agricultural Statistics Service) (2014) 2012 Census of Agriculture, Ohio State and County Data Volume 1. In: N.A.S., Ed., Service,
OEPA (2013) Ohio Lake Erie Phosphorus Task Force Final Report II. Ohio Environmental Protection Agency, Division of Surface Water, Columbus, OH.
Stumpf, R.P., Wynne, T.T., Baker, D.B. and Fahnestiel, G.L. (2012) Interannual Variability of Cyanobacterial Blooms in Lake Erie. PLoS ONE, 7, e42444. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0042444
Richards, R.P., Baker, D.B. and Crumrine, J.P. (2009) Improved Water Quality in Ohio tributaries to Lake Erie: A consequence of Conservation Practices. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation, 64, 200-211. https://doi.org/10.2489/jswc.64.3.200
Baker, D.B., Confesor, R., Ewing, D.E., Johnson, L.T., Kramer, J.W. and Merryfield, B.J. (2014) Phosphorus Loading to Lake Erie from the Maumee, Sandusky and Cuyahoga Rivers: The Importance of Bioavailability. Journal of Great Lakes Research, 40, 502-517. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jglr.2014.05.001
OEPA (2010) Ohio Lake Erie Phosphorus Task Force Final Report. Ohio Environmental Protection Agency, Division of Surface Water, Columbus, OH.
Ketterings, Q.M. and Czymmek, K.J. (2012) Phosphorus Index as a Phosphorus Awareness Tool: Documented Phosphorus Use Reduction in New York State. Journal of Environmental Quality, 41, 1767-1773. https://doi.org/10.2134/jeq2012.0050
Nelson, N.O. and Shober, A.L. (2012) Evaluation of Phosphorus Indices after Twenty Years of Science and Development. Journal of Environmental Quality, 41, 1703-1710. https://doi.org/10.2134/jeq2012.0342
Sharpley, A., Beegle, D., Bolster, C., Good, L., Joern, B., Ketterings, Q., Lory, J., Mikkelsen, R., Osmond, D. and Vadas, P. (2012) Phosphorus Indices: Why We Need to Take Stock of How We Are Doing. Journal of Environmental Quality, 41, 1711-1719. https://doi.org/10.2134/jeq2012.0040
Lemunyon, J. and Gilbert, R. (1993) The Concept and Need for a Phosphorus Assessment Tool. Journal of Production Agriculture, 6, 483-486. https://doi.org/10.2134/jpa1993.0483
USDA-NRCS-OH (2001) Nitrogen and Phosphorous Risk Assessment Procedures. http://efotg.sc.egov.usda.gov/references/public/OH/Nitrogen_and_Phosphorous_Risk_Assessment _Procedures.pdf
Benning, J.L. and Wortmann, C.S. (2005) Phosphorus Indexes in Four Midwestern States: An Evaluation of the Differences and Similarities. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation, 60, 221-227.
Sharpley, A.N., Daniel, T.C. and Edwards, D.R. (1993) Phosphorus Movement in the Landscape. Journal of Production Agriculture, 6, 492-500. https://doi.org/10.2134/jpa1993.0492
Sharpley, A.N., Weld, J.L., Beegle, D.B., Kleinman, P.J.A., Gburek, W.J., Moore, P.A. and Mullins, G. (2003) Development of Phosphorus Indices for Nutrient Management Planning Strategies in the United States. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation, 58, 137-152.
USDA-ARS (Agriculture Research Service) (2014) RUSLE2. http://www.ars.usda.gov/Research/docs.htm?docid=6038
Osmond, D.L., Cabrera, M.L., Feagley, S.E., Hardee, G.E., Mitchell, C.C., Moore, P.A., Mylavarapu, R.S., Oldham, J.L., Stevens, J.C., Thom, W.O., Walker, F. and Zhang, H. (2006) Comparing Ratings of the Southern Phosphorus Indices. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation, 61, 325-337.
Brandt, R.C. and Elliott, H.A. (2005) Sensitivity Analysis of the Pennsylvania Phosphorus Index for Agricultural Recycling of Municipal Biosolids. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation, 60, 209-219.
Jesiek, J. and Wolfe, M. (2005) Sensitivity Analysis of the Virginia Phosphorus Index Management Tool. Transactions of the American Society of Agricultural Engineers, 48, 1773-1781. https://doi.org/10.13031/2013.20011
Beaulieu, L., Gallichand, J., Duchemin, M. and Parent, L. (2006) Sensitivity Analysis of a Phosphorus Index for Quebec. Canadian Biosystems Engineering, 48, 13-24.
Bolster, C.H. and Vadas, P.A. (2013) Sensitivity and Uncertainty Analysis for the Annual Phosphorus Loss Estimator Model. Journal of Environmental Quality, 42, 1109-1118. https://doi.org/10.2134/jeq2012.0418
Williams, M.R., King, K.W., Dayton, E.A. and LaBarge, G. (2015) Sensitivity Analysis of the Ohio Phosphorus Risk Index. Transaction of the American Society of Agricultural Engineers, 58, 93-102.
Tiscareno-Lopez, M. (1991) Sensitivity Analysis of the WEPP Watershed Model. Master’s Thesis, School of Renewable Natural Resources, The University of Arizona, Tucson.
Jacomino, V.M.F. and Fields, D.E. (1997) A Critical Approach to the Calibration of a Watershed Model. Journal of the American Water Resources Association, 33, 143-154. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1752-1688.1997.tb04091.x
Roloff, G., de Jong, R. and Nolin, M.C. (1998) Crop Yield, Soil Temperature and Sensitivity of EPIC Under Central-Eastern Canadian Conditions. Canadian Journal of Soil Science, 78, 431-439. https://doi.org/10.4141/S97-087
Ma, L., Ascough II, J.C., Ahuja, L.R., Shaffer, M.J., Hanson, J.D. and Rojas, K.W. (2000) Root Zone Water Quality Model Sensitivity Analysis Using Monte Carlo Simulation. Transactions of American Society of Agricultural Engineers, 43, 883-895. https://doi.org/10.13031/2013.2984
Walker, S.E., Mitchell, J.K., Hirschi, M.C. and Johnsen, K.E. (2000) Sensitivity Analysis of the Root Zone Water Quality Model. Transaction of the American Society of Agricultural Engineers, 43, 841-846. https://doi.org/10.13031/2013.2978
Tattari, S., Bärlund, I., Rekolaninen, S., Posch, M., Siimes, K., Tuhkanen, H.-R. and Yli-Halla, M. (2001) Modeling Sediment Yield and Phosphorus Transport in Finnish Clayey Soils. Transaction of the American Society of Agricultural Engineers, 44, 297-307.
Dubus, I. and Brown, C. (2002) Sensitivity and First-Step Uncertainty Analyses for the Preferential Flow Model MACRO. Journal of Environmental Quality, 31, 13. https://doi.org/10.2134/jeq2002.2270
Ferreira, V.A., Weesies, G.A., Yoder, D.C., Foster, G.R. and Renard, K.G. (1995) The Site and Condition Specific Nature of Sensitivity Analysis. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation, 50, 493-497.
Lenhart, T., Eckhardt, K., Fohrer, N. and Frede, H.G. (2002) Comparison of Two Different Approaches of Sensitivity Analysis. Physics and Chemistry of the Earth, 27, 645-654. https://doi.org/10.1016/S1474-7065(02)00049-9
ESRI (2012) ArcMap 10.1. ESRI (Environmental Systems Resource Institute), Redlands.
USDA-NASS (National Agriculture Statistics Service) (2012) Cropland Data Layer. http://nassgeodata.gmu.edu/CropScape/
Soil-Survey-Staff (2013) The Gridded Soil Survey Geographic (gSSURGO) Database for Ohio. United States Department of Agriculture, Natural Resources Conservation Service.
U.S.-Geological-Survey (2013) National Hydrography Geodatabase: The National Map Viewer. http://viewer.nationalmap.gov/viewer/nhd.html?p=nhd
Barker, D., Beuerlein, J., Dorrance, A., Eckert, D., Eisley, B., Hammond, R., Lentz, E., Lipps, P., Loux, M., Mullen, R., Sulc, M., Thomison, P. and Watson, M. (2005) Ohio Agronomy Guide. 14th Edition, Ohio State University Extension, Bulletin 472, Columbus.
R Development Core Team (2015) R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna.
Eghball, B. and Gilley, J.E. (2001) Phosphorus Risk Assessment Index Evaluation Using Runoff Measurements. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation, 56, 202-206.
Ahmed, S.I., Mickelson, S.K., Pederson, C.H., Baker, J.L., Kanwar, R.S., Lorimor, J.C. and Webber, D. (2013) Swine Manure Rate, Timing, and Application Method Effects on Post-Harvest Soil Nutrients, Crop Yield, and Potential Water Quality Implications in a Corn-Soybean Rotation. Transactions of the American Society of Agricultural and Biological Engineers, 56, 395-408.
Daverede, I.C., Kravchenko, A.N., Hoeft, R.G., Nafziger, E.D., Bullock, D.G., Warren, J.J. and Gonzini, L.C. (2004) Phosphorus Runoff from Incorporated and Surface-Applied Liquid Swine Manure and Phosphorus Fertilizer. Journal of Environmental Quality, 33, 1535-1544. https://doi.org/10.2134/jeq2004.1535
Ginting, D., Moncrief, J.F., Gupta, S.C. and Evans, S.D. (1998) Interaction between Manure and Tillage System on Phosphorus Uptake and Runoff Losses. Journal of Environmental Quality, 27, 1403-1410. https://doi.org/10.2134/jeq1998.00472425002700060017x
Johnson, K.N., Kleinman, P.J.A., Beegle, D.B., Elliott, H.A. and Saporito, L.S. (2011) Effect of Dairy Manure Slurry Application in a No-Till System on Phosphorus Runoff. Nutrient Cycling in Agroecosystems, 90, 201-212. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10705-011-9422-8
Kimmell, R.J., Pierzynski, G.M., Janssen, K.A. and Barnes, P.L. (2001) Effects of Tillage and Phosphorus Placement on Phosphorus Runoff Losses in a Grain Sorghum—Soybean Rotation. Journal of Environmental Quality, 30, 1324-1330. https://doi.org/10.2134/jeq2001.3041324x
Little, J.L., Bennett, D.R. and Miller, J.J. (2005) Nutrient and Sediment Losses under Simulated Rainfall Following Manure Incorporation by Different Methods. Journal of Environmental Quality, 34, 1883-1895. https://doi.org/10.2134/jeq2005.0056
Kovar, J.L., Moorman, T.B., Singer, J.W., Cambardella, C.A. and Tomer, M.D. (2011) Swine Manure Injection with Low-Disturbance Applicator and Cover Crops Reduce Phosphorus Losses. Journal of Environmental Quality, 40, 329-336. https://doi.org/10.2134/jeq2010.0184
Mueller, D.H., Wendt, R.C. and Daniel, T.C. (1984) Phosphorus Losses as Affected by Tillage and Manure Application. Soil Science Society of America Journal, 48, 901-905. https://doi.org/10.2136/sssaj1984.03615995004800040040x
Tarkalson, D.D. and Mikkelsen, R.L. (2004) Runoff Phosphorus Losses as Related to Phosphorus Source, Application Method, and Application Rate on a Piedmont Soil. Journal of Environmental Quality, 33, 1424-1430. https://doi.org/10.2134/jeq2004.1424
Andraski, T.W. and Bundy, L.G. (2003) Relationships between Phosphorus Levels in Soil and in Runoff from Corn Production Systems. Journal of Environmental Quality, 32, 310-316. https://doi.org/10.2134/jeq2003.3100
Pautler, M.C. and Sims, J.T. (2000) Relationships between Soil Test Phosphorus, Soluble Phosphorus, and Phosphorus Saturation in Delaware Soils. Soil Science Society of America Journal, 64, 765-773. https://doi.org/10.2136/sssaj2000.642765x
Pote, D.H., Daniel, T.C., Moore, P.A., Nichols, D.J., Sharpley, A.N. and Edwards, D.R. (1996) Relating Extractable Soil Phosphorus to Phosphorus Losses in Runoff. Soil Science Society of America Journal, 60, 855-859. https://doi.org/10.2136/sssaj1996.03615995006000030025x
Sharpley, A., Daniel, T.C., Sims, J.T. and Pote, D.H. (1996) Determining Environmentally Sound Soil Phosphorus Levels. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation, 51, 160-166.
Torbert, H.A., Daniel, T.C., Lemunyon, J.L. and Jones, R.M. (2002) Relationship of Soil Test Phosphorus and Sampling Depth to Runoff Phosphorus in Calcareous and Noncalcareous Soils. Journal of Environmental Quality, 31, 1380-1387. https://doi.org/10.2134/jeq2002.1380