The Controversy over the Basic Philosophical Disciplines of Metaphysics and Ontology
- 1 St. Robert Bellarmine Church, Liverpool, UK
Abstract
The modern readings of the history of philosophy have led some scholars to attempt to reinvent or reconstruct the subject of metaphysics. These attempts had significant consequences on the Aristotelian model of metaphysics and its status as First Philosophy as listed by the ancient commentators, Alexander of Aphrodisias or Theophrastus. These new trends of philosophy also altered the dynamics of abstraction upon which Aristotle built a convincing theory of science according to the structures of discursive reasoning. The trend did not begin until after what historians termed the “second beginning of metaphysics in the thirteenth century.” The current paper investigates the historical development and controversy surrounding the understanding of the two philosophical terms and the consequences of replacing metaphysics with ontology as the First Philosophy.
- Aquinas, T. (1992). Super Boetium de Trinitate, cura et studio Fratrum Praedicatorum and Expositio libri Boetii de Hebdomadibus (Vol. 50). Leonina (Ed.).
- Aristotle (1984). Metaphysics. In J. Barnes (Ed.), The Complete Works of Aristotle: The Revised Oxford Translation (pp. 3343-3713). Princeton University Press.
- Boethius, A. M. S. (1968). De Trinitate II. In H. F. Stewart, & E. K. Rand (Eds.), The Theological Tractates, the Consolation of Philosophy (pp. 5-20). William Heinemann.
- Chenu, M.-D. (1976). La théologie au douzième siècle (Etudes de Philosophie Medievale 45) (pp. 142-158). Librairie Philosophique J Vrin.
- Duma, T. (2021). Separation as the Basic Method of Realistic Metaphysics: The Approach by the Lublin Philosophical School Representatives. Studia Gilsoniana, 10, 611-633.
- Goclenius, R. (1988). Isagoge in Primam Philosophiam. In C. B. Schmitt (Ed.), The Cambridge History in Renaissance Philosophy (pp. 169-170). Cambridge University Press.
- Husserl, E. (1913). Ideen zu einer reinen Phãnomenologie. Meiner.
- Ingarden, R. (1925). über die Stellung der Erkenntnistheorie im System der Philosophie (Habilitationsvortrag). Karras, Kröber & Nietschmann.
- Ingarden, R. (1964). Der Streit um die Existenz der Welt I: Existentialontologie. Niemeyer.
- Ingarden, R. (1965). Der Streit um die Existenz der Welt II/1: Formalontologie [The Controversy over the Existence of the World]. Niemeyer.
- John Paul II (2005). Encyclical Letter, Fides et Ratio. In Pope John Paul II Encyclicals (pp. 57-102). Carmel International Publishing House.
- Krapiec, M., & Maryniarczyk, A. (2010). The Lublin Philosophical School. Polskie Towarzystwo Tomasza Z Akwinu.
- Lohr, C. H. (1988). Metaphysics. In C. B. Schmitt (Ed.), The Cambridge History in Renaissance Philosophy (pp. 537-638). Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/CHOL9780521251044.018
- Loux, M. J. (2006). Metaphysics or Ontology? The Debate about the Subject-Matter of First Philosophy. In J. Kim, & E. Sosa (Eds.), Metaphysics. A Contemporary Introduction (pp. 2-5). Routledge.
- McInerny, R. (1990). Boethius and Aquinas. The Catholic University of America Press.
- Meixner, U. (2004). Einführung in die Ontologie [Introduction to Ontology]. Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft.