This paper deals with the inaccuracy assessment of the friction pressure loss estimation based on Darcy formula combined with an equivalent hydraulic diameter and a friction factor valid for circular pipes when applied to a square rod bundle. The assessment has been done by comparing the analytical and semi-empirical predictions with two different CFD codes results: CFX and NEPTUNE_CFD. Two different analytical approaches have been considered: the whole-bundle and sub-channel approaches, both for laminar and turbulent flow conditions. Looking at results, it is reasonable to assume that an error in the range of 11% - 23% is likely when using equivalent diameter in the laminar regime. In the case of turbulent regime, the equivalent diameter works better and the error is in the range between a few percent and ~12%.
KeywordsHydraulic DiameterPressure LossesAccuracy
Rheme, K. (1973) Simple Method of Prediction Friction Factors of Turbulent Flow in Non-Circular Channels. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 16, 933-950. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0017-9310(73)90033-1
Cheng, S. and Todreas, N.E. (1986) Hydrodynamic Models and Correlations for Bare and Wire-Wrapped Hexagonal Rod Bundles-Bundle Friction Factors, Subchannel Friction Factors and Mixing Parameters. Nuclear Engineering and Design, 92, 227-251. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0029-5493(86)90249-9
Lee, K.B. (1995) Analytical Prediction of Subchannel Friction Factor for Infinite Bare Rod Square and Triangular Arrays of Low Pitch to Diameter Ratio in Turbulent Flow. Nuclear Engineering and Design, 157, 197-203. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0029-5493(95)00996-P
Ahmed, S. and Brundrett, E. (1971) Characteristic Lengths for Non-Circular Ducts. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 14, 157-159. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0017-9310(71)90147-5
He, S. and Gotts, J.A. (2004) Calculation of Friction Coefficients for Noncircular Channels. Journal of Fluids Engineering, 126, 1033-1038. http://dx.doi.org/10.1115/1.1845479
Laviéville, J., Boucker, M., Quémérais, E., Mimouni, S. and Méchitoua N. (2006) NEPTUNE CFD V1.0 Theory Manual, EDF.
Laviéville, J., Boucker, M., Quémérais, E. and Maas, L. (2005) NEPTUNE CFD V1.0 User Guide, EDF.
ANSYS CFX 14, User Manual, Ansys-CFX, 2012.
D’Auria, F. and Galassi, G. (2010) Scaling in Nuclear Reactor System Thermal-Hydraulics. Nuclear Engineering and Design, 240, 3267-3293. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.nucengdes.2010.06.010
Moretti, F. and D’Auria, F. (2014) Accuracy Quantification Metrics for CFD Simulation of In-Vessel Flows. Nuclear Engineering and Design, 279, 200-209. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.nucengdes.2014.03.003
Moretti, F., Melideo, D., D’Auria, F., Hohrne, T. and Klein, S. (2008) CFX Simulations of ROCOM Slug Mixing Experiments. Journal of Power and Energy Systems, 2, 720-733. http://dx.doi.org/10.1299/jpes.2.720
Bucalossi, A., Moretti, F., Melideo, D., Del Nevo, A., D’Auria, F., Hohrne, T., Lisenkov, E. and Gallori, D. (2011) Experimental Investigation of In-Vessel Mixing Phenomena in a VVER-1000 Scaled Test Facility during Unsteady Asymmetric Transients. Nuclear Engineering and Design, 241, 3068-3075. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.nucengdes.2011.05.005
Moretti, F., Melideo, D., Del Nevo, A., D’Auria, F., Hohrne, T. and Lisenkov, E. (2009) CFD Analysis of a Slug Mixing Experiment Conducted on a VVER-1000 Model. Science and Technology of Nuclear Installations, 2009, Article ID: 436218. http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2009/436218
Mahaffy, J., Chung, U.B., Dubois, F., Ducros, F., Graffard, E., Heitsch, M., Henriksson, M., Komen, E., Moretti, F., Morii, T., Muhulbauer, P., Rohde, U., Scheuerer, M., Smith, B.L., Song, C., Watanabe, T. and Zingh, G. (2007) Best Practice Guidelines for the Use of CFD in Nuclear Reactor Safety Applications. NEA/CSNI/R (2007)5, May 2007.
D’Auria, F., Camargo, C. and Mazzantini, O. (2012) The Best Estimate plus Uncertainty (BEPU) Approach in Licensing of Current Nuclear Reactors. Nuclear Engineering and Design, 248, 317-328. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.nucengdes.2012.04.002
Todreas, N.E. and Kazimi, M.S. (1990) Nuclear Systems I Thermal Hydraulic Fundamentals. Taylor & Francis Group, LLC, New York.
Colebrook, C.F. (1939) Turbulent Flow in Pipes, with Particular Reference to the Transition Region between the Smooth and Rough Pipe Laws. Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers, 11, 133-156. http://dx.doi.org/10.1680/ijoti.1939.13150
Moody, L.F. (1944) Friction Factors for Pipe Flow. Transactions of the ASME, 66, 671-684.
Xu, Y., Fang, X., Su, X., Zhou, Z. and Chen, W. (2012) Evaluation of Frictional Pressure Drop Correlations for Two Phase Flow in Pipes. Nuclear Engineering and Design, 253, 86-97. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.nucengdes.2012.08.007
Genic, S., Arandjelovic, I., Kolendic, P., Jaric, M., Budimir, N. and Genic, V. (2011) A Review of Explicit Approximations of Colebrook’s Equation. FME Transactions, 39, 67-71.
Garland, J. (1998) Single Phase Friction Factor for MNR Thermal-Hydraulic Modelling. Technical Report 1998-02, McMaster University, Hamilton.
Gunn, D.J. and Darling, C.W.W. (1963) Fluid Flow and Energy Losses in Non-Circular Conduits. Transactions of the Institution of Chemical Engineers, 41, 163-173.
Yan, J., Yuan, K., Tatli, E., Huegel, D. and Karoutas, Z. (2010) CFD Prediction of Pressure Drop for Inlet Region of a PWR Fuel Assembly. Workshop Proceedings, CFD4NRS-3, Bethesda, 14-16 September 2010.
Capone, L. (2012) CFD Analysis of Nuclear Fuel Bundles and Spacer Grids for PWR Reactors. Doctoral Dissertation, Office of Graduate Studies of Texas A&M University, College Station.
Kays, W.M. (1966) Convective Heat and Mass Transfer. MacGraw-Hill, New York.
Sparrow, E.M. and Loeffler Jr., A.L. (1959) Longitudinal Laminar Flow between Cylinders Arranged in Regular Array. AIChE Journal, 5, 325-330. http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/aic.690050315
Deissler, R.G. and Taylor, M.F. (1957) Analysis of Axial Turbulent Flow and Heat Transfer through Banks of Rods and Tubes. Proceeding from Reactor Heat Transfer Conference, Part 1 Book 2. TID-7529 USAEC 1957.
Le Tourneau, B.W., Grimble, R.E. and Zerbe, J.E. (1957) Pressure Drop for Parallel Flow through Rod Bundles. Transactions of the ASME, 79, 83.
Trupp, A.C. and Azad, R.S. (1975) Structure of Turbulent Flow in Triangular Rod Bundles. Nuclear Engineering and Design, 32, 47-84. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0029-5493(75)90090-4
Carasik, L.B., Shaver, D.R. and Hassan, Y.A. (2015) Sensitivity of Boundary Conditions and Flow Domain for Pressure Drop Estimation for Molten Salts in a Crossflow Tube Bundle, Conference Paper.
In, W.K. and Oh, T.H.C. (2001) Pressure Drop Correlation for a PWR Fuel Assembly with Mixing Vane. Proceeding of the Korean Nuclear Society Spring Meeting, Cheju, 24-25 May 2001.
Smith III, L.D., Corner, M.E., Liu, B., Dzodzo, B., Paramonov, D.V., Beaslley, D.E., Langford, H.M. and Hollowey, M.V. (2002) Benchmarking Computational Fluid Dynamics for Application to PWR Assembly. Proceeding of the 10th ICONE Conference, Arlington, 14-18 April 2002, 823-830.